Dominic (who many of you know) wrote an excellent response which was ignored but made some really good points
http://www.searchen.com/forum/showpo...2&postcount=28
There is further talk in that thread of closing up the forum entirely to new members which I further can't understand seeing as how in another post, John stated that the majority of people visiting are coming through Google searches (which would dry up if pages weren't indexed).
I suppose they can make the Google IPs members but then of course you can just spoof them to get around the membership fee.
Very ballsy for a forum which I remember getting a PM in SEOCrap askingme to support it and post a bit.