If you are ranking well and not seeing much traffic, how are you determining you have a first page ranking? If you are looking a Google search and are logged into your account, try logging out and re-run the search. With the "personal" stuff G is doing now, you might find the results quite different when you do log out. I found this out the hard way a ways back. SEOCentro has in there set of free online tools a rank checker. Try that as well.
Last edited by JohnWoodward; 02-05-2012 at 05:04 PM.