Rate my new logo (Gaming Forums)

[Mark07]

I liked the one which is a slightly different version. The second one. The color combination is good compared to the third one. I will give the 2nd one a 6/10.

[edyst3]

I like the different version which using .com on it. 7/10

[Hot Cocoa]

Why is the K larger than the rest of the text? It almost reads "A F K kay?"
I recommend looking at some logo books like logolounge and examining how other professionals approach typographic logo treatments. As it stands, if a designer came to me with this logo, I'd thank him/her for their time and show him the door.

That's the harsh part of it. The good news is you're doing this for yourself and it's a learning process. So lets learn. Try putting all the letter together at the same size again. then play with perspective, some psuedo 3d. Try integrating your tagline with the rest of the logo. Try doing all of this in black and white. Play with the shapes. When you have something that looks good in black and white, then add some color back into it. Then explore value, rich vs muted tones. then start playing with distressing or glossing or other rendering techniques. THEN go on to your backgrounds and site design.

It's gonna take some time. The last logo I worked on took 3 months and accrued $54,000 in billable hours. I had the benefit of working on it with other designers and Art Directors. But the key is keep pushing it, and keep getting feedback from others.

But when it's done, it gonna kick ass. And that's what you really want right?

[krahmaan]

Originally Posted by dpatel304

Here is my new one:
Attachment 6776

I like this one, better than the slightly different version. Cool.
On a scale from 1-10 I give it an 8!

[Seonewoffer]

Latest one is good

[Kryvast]

I like the arrangement of the second one.

[NanTheMan4]

last one is better

[m42]

Rating 5/10 for 1. 6/10 for 2. Both are a bit difficult to read. There's a bit too much clutter and background noise.

I'm a big fan of less is more.

[rayanaga]

I like the second on better but they both look good to me!

[gommer683]

7/10 as well, it is very recognizable.

[mingscians]

can anyone design logo for my site <snip>. It's a flash online gaming site. If you are interested tell me how much it will cost us.

[smut]

Not bad, 6/10

[Jacob34]

betterish from what ya had but the last one was not even that bad

[mcwb201]

i prefer the first one